By Dr. Chris Cormier, DC
Not a little. Not a tasteful amount applied once at the mirror. My father put on cologne in layers, the way you would paint a fence, and he did it with complete confidence.
You knew when he had been in a room. You knew roughly how long ago. It lived in the car. It lived in the hallway. It got into the upholstery and stayed there, and I suspect it is still in some of that furniture now.
I thought it was wonderful. I was a boy who wanted to be like his father, and this was one of the few parts of being a grown man that was available to me, so I started doing it too — badly, and in the same quantities, which on a twelve-year-old is a decision everybody around him has to live with.
Then I learned things
What happens next is the ordinary arc of a career in health. You read. You keep reading. You start looking at labels on everything, and then you start noticing what the labels do not say.
I became careful. That is the polite word for it. I stopped wearing cologne altogether, and I have not worn any for a long time now. Some of my family still do, and I have never made it a campaign — but for myself, I decided I would rather not put something on my skin every morning when I could not find out what was in it.
There was no dramatic moment. I did not throw anything away in disgust. The bottle simply moved to the back of a shelf and then at some point it was not there any more, and I could not tell you which year that happened. That is how most of our real decisions get made — not announced, just quietly stopped.
I still think that reasoning is sound. I wrote about the habit it comes from, and its limits, in I test everything on myself first.
What I did not do, at any point in that process, was account for what I was giving up.
What I gave up
Here is the thing I understood only much later, and I understood it professionally before I understood it personally, which is a familiar order of events for me.
Smell is the only sense that reaches your memory and emotional centres without being relayed through the middle of the brain first. The signal arrives at the structures that handle feeling and recall before you have consciously worked out what you are smelling. My colleagues at The Nerve Health Institute set out the full anatomy in why smells trigger memories.
Which is the answer to why a smell reminds you of someone with a force that a photograph cannot manage. A photograph is information about a person. A smell is closer to an ambush.
My father was not trying to smell good. I am fairly sure he thought he was. What he was actually doing, every single morning for decades, was installing himself in me.
And it worked. It worked so well that I can summon it now, sitting here, without a bottle in the building.
And then I walked past somebody
Years after I stopped, I was in a store doing something unremarkable, and a man walked past me going the other way.
I had the whole response before I had a single thought. Something went through my chest, my eyes did what eyes do, and only afterwards — a second later, maybe two — did the actual information arrive: that is the cologne. That is my father.
I want to be precise about the order, because the order is the entire point. The feeling was not a reaction to the recognition. The feeling came first and the recognition caught up. I have spent my career explaining that pathway to patients and I still was not ready for it in a shop aisle on an ordinary afternoon.
I did not turn around. I stood there for a moment like a man who had remembered he left the oven on, and then I carried on with my errand.
Why it is people, specifically
People ask why a smell reminds you of someone rather than of a place or an object, and the answer is that it does both — but people land harder, and there is a reason for it.
The pathway that scent takes runs through the structures handling emotion. So what gets encoded most strongly is not the most frequent smell in your life but the most emotionally loaded one. Your childhood home, the person who raised you, the one who was there when something important happened.
There is also a timing effect that I find genuinely moving. Memories cued by a smell tend to come from earlier in life than memories cued by words or pictures — researchers have found scent-cued recollections clustering around early childhood, well before the age range that usually dominates autobiographical memory. Small children take the world in through their noses long before they are doing much of it with language.
So the smells that got my father into me got there before I had the words to describe him. That is a strange thing to sit with. Whatever I would say about my father now is a later construction. The cologne is the original file.
The part I have come around to
For years I told this story as a straightforward improvement. Boy copies father, boy grows up, boy learns better, boy stops. Progress.
I am less sure of that telling than I used to be.
Not because I think I was wrong about the labels — I was not, and I would make the same call today. But because somewhere in the process of becoming careful about what I put on my body, I quietly deleted a direct line to my father and did not notice I was doing it, because nothing about the decision felt like a loss at the time. It felt like information.
That is the thing about becoming careful. It is almost always correct in the particular and it has a cost in the aggregate that nobody tracks, because each individual decision is so obviously sensible that you never total them up.
I see the same pattern in people who arrive at my clinic having eliminated eleven things. Every elimination was reasonable. Each one had an article behind it and a sensible-sounding argument, and I could not fault any single decision if you put it in front of me on its own.
Nobody ever asks what the eleven of them cost together. Not in symptoms — in life. The meals not shared, the invitations declined, the small pleasures quietly removed on the grounds that something better was theoretically available. I have watched people become so careful that there was very little left that they were still allowed to enjoy, and not one of them could point to the decision where it went too far, because there was not one. There were eleven, and all of them were fine.
What I would say to you about it
Three things, and they cost nothing. They are what I would say to anybody who has understood why a smell reminds you of someone and wants to do something sensible with that.
If a scent is a person to you, keep it
Not in a drawer you never open. Somewhere you can get to it. You are not keeping a bottle, you are keeping a route, and routes close when they are not used.
But do not wear it every day
This is the counterintuitive one and it matters. A scent that becomes part of your ordinary background stops being a signal and turns into wallpaper. The association survives on scarcity. If you want a smell to keep meaning somebody, let it stay unusual — which is the same mechanism Body Charger uses deliberately in how to use scent for sleep, pointed in the opposite direction.
It is also why I would not wear a scent I loved to a hospital appointment, a point EBOO Prime makes in what to leave at home on procedure day. You do not get to choose what a scent attaches itself to. You only get to choose what you expose it to.
And choose what you are careful about on purpose
Being careful is good. Being careful about everything, by reflex, is a different thing, and it quietly removes a great deal from a life without ever announcing itself.
So pick. Be genuinely rigorous about the handful of things that matter most to you, and let some of the rest go. I would rather somebody read one label properly than approach their whole life as a hazard assessment.
Where I have landed
I am not going back to cologne. That part of the decision has held, and I expect it to keep holding.
But I have stopped telling the story as a clean win, because it was not one. It was a trade, and I made it without seeing the other side of the ledger. The other side was a man walking into a room ten minutes before you noticed him, and a boy who thought that was the finest thing he had ever smelled.
If you have somebody like that, and there is a smell attached to them, I would not be too quick to be sensible about it. I have written about other things my patients have taught me about what we notice too late in the thing people tell me last and I’m the age of my patients now.
My father wore too much cologne. It was objectively too much. I would not change a thing about it.
Questions people ask me about this
Why does a smell remind you of someone so strongly?
Because smell is the only sense that reaches the brain’s emotion and memory centres without being relayed through the thalamus first. The signal gets to the structures handling feeling and recall before you have identified the smell, which is why the response arrives ahead of the explanation.
Why are scent memories usually from so long ago?
Memories cued by smell tend to come from earlier in life than those cued by words or images, clustering in early childhood rather than in the later range that normally dominates autobiographical memory. Young children take in a great deal through smell before language takes over.
Should I keep a bottle of someone’s perfume or cologne?
If it means something to you, yes, and somewhere accessible rather than buried. I would not use it daily though. A scent that becomes ordinary background stops working as a signal, and the association you are trying to protect depends on it staying unusual.
More essays
I write about what practice teaches you, as opposed to what you expected it to. The rest is at drchriscormier.com/writing, there is more about me at about, and you can reach me through contact.
Spark your cells to optimal longevity.
— Dr. Chris Cormier, DC








