The Most Flattering Thing a Patient Can Say to Me

By Dr. Chris Cormier, DC

It usually comes about twenty minutes in, and it is always some version of the same thing.

Nobody else could find it. You are the first person who has actually listened to me.

I want to write about that sentence, because it is the nicest thing anybody says to me in a working week — and it is the one I have learned to be most careful with.

What is true in it

A good deal, and I do not want to talk anyone out of it.

People genuinely do get dismissed. Appointments are short, and a person who cannot name their symptom precisely can walk out with nothing. Feeling unheard is not a character flaw or an overreaction — it is an extremely common experience, and most people carrying it around have earned it honestly.

It is also true that a normal test is not the same thing as a complete picture. Tests answer the specific question they were designed to answer. Something can be measurably fine and functionally not fine, and I spend a good part of my working life in that gap. It is a real gap. I am not pretending otherwise.

So when somebody says nobody could find it, they are usually describing something that actually happened to them. The sentence is nearly always sincere, and it is often accurate.

Why I have learned to be careful with it

Because of what it does to the person hearing it.

That sentence hands me a role, and the role is enormously appealing. I am the one who found it. I am the one who listened. Everybody else missed it and I did not. There is no practitioner alive who does not enjoy being handed that, and anybody in this field who claims otherwise is not paying attention to themselves.

The trouble is that the role comes with an instruction attached, and the instruction is: keep looking here. Sometimes that is right. Sometimes the honest answer is keep looking, but not here — and the better I feel about being the person who found it, the harder that second sentence is to say.

A practitioner who enjoys being the last resort is a practitioner who will hold on to someone slightly too long. Not out of greed. Out of being flattered, which is quieter and much harder to notice in yourself.

And it does something to the person saying it, too, which I think about more than the other half. Once somebody has decided that one practitioner is the only one who understands them, they tend to stop looking anywhere else. They have found their answer, and the relief of that is enormous after months of feeling dismissed. I have watched people turn down a referral because accepting it would have meant going back out into the world that did not listen.

So the sentence does not just flatter me. It can quietly close doors on the person who said it — and I am the one holding the handle.

I have done it

Early on, more than once. Not dramatically and not with any harm that I know of, but I held on to people I should have moved along faster, and the reason was not clinical.

The reason was that they had told me I was the one who understood, and I wanted to go on being that. So I kept working the problem from my own angle for a few more weeks than the situation deserved, when the useful thing would have been to say: this part is not mine, go and get it ruled out, and come back to me afterwards.

I have written before about the professional pleasure of being able to do something, and the discipline of not doing it, in I built a reputation on not doing this. This is the same muscle, used on a different temptation. That one is about the urge to intervene. This one is about the urge to be the only one who can.

The two questions

What I do now is unglamorous, and it takes about ninety seconds.

The first question is: is this actually mine? Not could I plausibly help, because I can almost always plausibly help. Is this problem, as described, in the territory I am trained and equipped for? Those are different questions and the second one is much narrower.

The second is: what would have to be true for me to be wrong? If the answer to that involves anything that gets worse while you wait, it stops being a question I get to sit with. It becomes a phone call.

That gives me a rule I can apply without having to feel wise in the moment. Anything that could be time-critical goes to the person who can rule it out, today, and we carry on afterwards. Not instead of my care. Before it, and alongside it.

It sounds obvious written down. In the room, with somebody telling you that you are the only one who has ever taken them seriously, it is not obvious at all. That is exactly why it has to be a rule rather than a judgement call.

Both things are true at once

Here is the part I find genuinely difficult to hold, and I think most people do.

“We cannot find anything” from a careful clinician does not mean there is nothing. That is real, and a lot of people live in that gap for years.

And — at the same time — a normal test is not nothing. It is a door closed, often the most important door, by someone whose entire job is closing that specific door properly. Treating a clear result as meaningless is not open-mindedness. It is just a different way of ignoring information.

The way I try to hold both is to treat a clear result as information rather than a verdict. It tells me what this is not, which is genuinely valuable and narrows the field considerably. It does not tell me what it is. Ruling things out is most of medicine, and it works — it is simply slower and less satisfying than being told the answer.

The honest position is awkward and unsatisfying: keep looking, and keep looking in the right direction. Those are not in tension. They only feel that way when somebody is selling you one of them.

What I would say to you, if you are the one who feels unheard

Four things, briefly.

Go back rather than going sideways. If something still feels wrong, the most useful next step is usually another conversation in the same discipline — a second opinion from someone who does that work — rather than a different field entirely. Sideways feels like progress and is often just movement.

Ask the specific question. “What would it look like if this were something serious, and what have we ruled out?” is a far better question than “are you sure?”. It gives the person opposite something concrete to answer, and most of them will answer it well.

Say the whole thing early, including the undignified part. I have written about what people hold back until the door in the thing people tell me last. A symptom mentioned in minute two gets investigated. The same symptom mentioned on the way out gets a nod.

And be wary of anybody — me included — who tells you that the tests are wrong and they alone can see it. That sentence feels like being believed. It is not the same thing as being helped.

The compliment I would rather have

If I am honest about what I actually want said about me, it is not that I found what nobody else could.

It is that somebody came in, got sorted out, stopped needing to come in, and forgot my name. That is a much better outcome and a considerably worse story, which is probably why nobody says it.

I wrote recently about discovering that half my job is adding what is missing and the other half is making sure something ends, in I thought my job was to give people more. This is a version of the same correction. The ending is part of the work. Being needed indefinitely is not a compliment — it is a result, and usually not a very good one.

So when somebody tells me that nobody else could find it, I have learned to say thank you, and then to ask myself the two questions before I let myself enjoy it. Usually the answer is that it is mine and we carry on. Sometimes it is a phone call, and those are the appointments I am proudest of, even though nobody has ever thanked me for one.

I have written elsewhere about declining to overrule people who knew better than me, in the answer they wanted me to give. It turns out a surprising amount of this job is working out which of us, today, is the right person for the problem — and being honest when it is not me.

If something has changed and you are weighing up whether to get it looked at, the clinic has written on the signs worth acting on quickly. If it is someone else you are worried about, BodyCharger has a practical piece on getting them to go. And if you are in the gap between a test and a result, EBOO Prime has written on getting through the wait.

More of what I have written is at the writing page. How I came to practise this way is the about page, and you can always get in touch.

Dr. Chris Cormier, DC

Lafayette, Louisiana

Clinic care at nervehealth.com. At-home protocols at bodycharger.com. Circulation and oxygenation at ebooprime.com.

Spark your cells to optimal longevity.

Recent Post

  • All Posts
My Mother Had It Too

By Dr. Chris Cormier, DC It usually arrives in the first five minutes, and almost always unprompted. My mother had...